“Smokeless
Tobacco, Oral Pathology Prevention And Awareness Network (STOP PAAN)”
Jyotsna Changrani MD, MPH, Francesca Gany MD, MS, Gustavo Cruz DMD, MPH, Ralph
Katz PhD, Ross Kerr DMD
Introduction:
Smokeless tobacco and areca nut consumption in various forms is an integral
cultural tradition in India, and is also popular among Indian immigrants in
the United Kingdom, other parts of Europe, North America, and Australia. The
United States is home to over 1.67 million ‘Asian Indians.’ As Indians
have emigrated and resettled in countries across the world, they have continued
consuming the various culturally-linked tobacco products, including paan and
gutka. Studies in the U.K., South and East Africa, and the Malay Peninsula report
this pattern. Very limited research exists on South Asians in the United States.
Extensive searches on Medline, Pubmed, and the World Wide Web yielded no studies
on oral cancer and smokeless tobacco use in South Asian immigrants in the United
States. The STOP PAAN pilot study is exploring gutka and paan consumption in
South Asian immigrants in New York.
Objectives: The pilot study has developed a questionnaire to: a) explore the
social, economic, and cultural context of gutka and paan consumption in the
South Asian communities in New York City; b) explore knowledge about health
consequences and risk of oral cancer posed by use of gutka and paan; and c)
determine attitudes towards, and barriers to, use of dental services, which
would contribute to the detection of oral cancer cases. In developing the questionnaire,
existing instruments were considered. Focus groups with the community guided
the development of the questionnaire. The questionnaire was piloted in New York
and at King Edward Memorial Hospital in Mumbai, India.
Results: The questionnaire has been administered in New York at community-based
sites, including grocery stores, social organizations, and places of residence.
139 first-generation Indian immigrant adults have been surveyed at these community
sites to date. Preliminary data has been analyzed on 41 of these participants,
including 22 men and 19 women. Mean participant age was 49.24 years (SD=13.90);
mean duration of residence in the United States was 9.8 years (SD=7.23). Over
45% of the men reported current regular use of gutka, and nearly 14% reported
past regular use of gutka. Nearly 55% of the sample reported past use of paan;
fewer than 5% reported current use of paan. Only 18% reported no regular use
of paan or gutka. In contrast, no women reported past or current regular use
of gutka. Over 26% reported past use of paan and no women reported current use
of paan. Forty percent of the current users of gutka were past users of paan,
who cited switching to gutka upon moving to the U.S. as a matter of convenience.
Ninety-five percent of all persons either heard of someone getting oral cancer
or knew that you could get cancer in the mouth. Of the 85% who replied yes to
the question, “Do you think gutka causes oral cancer?,” 90% of the
current gutka users said yes to the same question. STOP PAAN is working with
biostatisticians at New York University College of Dentistry to complete the
data analysis.
Next Steps: The STOP PAAN work has been presented at two conferences to date
in New York and Philadelphia. A manuscript, “Paan and Gutka: An Emerging
U.S. Threat” has been submitted to the Journal of Immigrant Health. The
results of the STOP PAAN pilot will be prepared as a manuscript for publication.
Additionally, the following grants are in development, or have been recently
funded, building on the STOP PAAN pilot work:
(1) The New York State Department of Health, Office of Minority Health recently
funded a project to: (a) increase awareness about the risk of cancer posed by
paan and gutka in the South Asian immigrant communities in New York City, and
(b) screen South Asian immigrants in New York City for oral lesions related
to gutka and paan use. Culturally-appropriate messages on smokeless tobacco
prevention for written media broadcast will be developed and a STOP PAAN community
campaign will be undertaken in 2004-2005. The impact of these efforts in the
community will be measured.
(2) A pilot project has been funded by the Research for Adolescent and Adult
Health Promotion Center at New York College of Dentistry to develop a training
program for oral cancer screening, and to test the ability of health care providers
with minimal background in the diagnosis of oral diseases to independently perform
oral cancer screenings in an outreach setting and accurately document oral findings.
The pilot is being conducted in India.
(3) An international collaborative planning grant has been prepared to study
the rising incidence of cancer of the tongue and mouth among young individuals.
The purpose of this “Oral Cancer Among Young” (OCAY) grant proposal
is to bring together a group of international researchers from the U.S., Europe,
and Asia through collaborative partnerships to conduct research according to
a common protocol to address the rising incidence of cancer of the tongue and
mouth among youth in different parts of the world. STOP PAAN is working as a
part of a team of local and international researchers on oral cancer. It is
in the process of being submitted to the National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial
Research (NIDCR).
(4) An R21 application, “Gutka Cessation Study,” (GCS) was developed
and submitted to the NCI on October 1, 2003. The GCS is designed as an R21 preliminary
study to: (a) determine whether gutka chewers are interested in quitting and,
if yes, to describe characteristics of those who are motivated to quit, and
determine the facilitators and inhibitors to quitting; (b) develop and test
a scale to measure dependence in gutka users; and (3) determine the preferred
cessation intervention for gutka users according to their readiness to quit.
(5) STOP PAAN is working with the New York State Oral Cancer Control Partnership
to develop two projects. The first project is to develop, implement, and evaluate
a training intervention to increase the rates of oral cancer examinations for
at risk patients at Bellevue Hospital, and to evaluate the impact of disseminating
oral cancer educational materials among Bellevue’s outpatient population.
The second project is to develop and compare community educational efforts versus
community education with targeted oral cancer screenings for populations at
high risk for oral cancer; and to develop, evaluate, and widely disseminate
culturally-appropriate educational materials and interventions for populations
at high risk for oral cancer.